Every Chinese EV You Sell Is a Camry You Didn’t
TOM’S TAKE
Hey guys and ladies. I’m in a dealer-to-dealer mood today. I’m not here to show anybody I know more than you, because I don’t, and that kind of talk never built anything where we’re worth something to each other.
In the last year I’ve probably had more than 75 dealers come to me asking what I know about how this business of importing EVs from China is going to work. I know I’ve got a different take on it than a lot of dealers, so here’s what a year of living with this has told me about the whole program.
It sucks.
The government doesn’t know squat about selling cars
My only takeaway is something most good dealer people already know: the government doesn’t know squat about any part of the car business.
Remember how we got here. In 2024 Washington put a 100% tariff on Chinese EVs, and Ottawa followed right behind with its own 100% that October. Nobody cried much. Chinese cars were thought of as the new Yugo or Lada. We know what the Lada did for Canada. The Yugo was worse down south, with Malcolm Bricklin set to flood America with them. All twelve cars. Six sold. Half a flood.
Then this January, with Mark Carney and Donald Trump in a full-blown pissing contest, Ottawa did a U-turn: 49,000 Chinese EVs a year at 6.1%. Washington kept its 100%. Don’t put anything away yet, boys. That contest is just getting started.
49,000 cars. For the year.
When I heard 49,000, I thought, great. At least we start getting cars, and maybe 100 dealers across Canada get a solid month’s worth to sell because of price, like I lived through once.
It was 1984. We were Korea Kar in Mississauga and Tiger Motorsport in Toronto, and we sold brand-new Hyundai Ponys at $3,995 like ice cream cones in July. Hyundai shipped cars as we needed them, not on a quota. The factory figured we’d sell 400 in a year. We did it in the first seven weeks. Different dollars today, but the same idea as a well-priced Chinese EV.
Except 49,000 isn’t a month’s supply. It’s every dealer in the country for a whole year. And it isn’t only for the new Chinese brands; Tesla’s Shanghai-built cars come out of the same pile. By September, only about 15,600 had actually landed. So of course each dealer is going to get his twelve cars for the year, plus his minimum initial allotment.
Then somebody at the factory end said, “Hey, this is cars. We’ve been doing this for 125 years.” They counted the numbers, counted the dealers, counted the brands, and said to heck with it, we’ll come and do this ourselves. And they stayed polite and stayed the course when they were told: actually, you’re not getting any cars in 2026, because Elon got them all.
What dealers are being told now is that there’ll be 25,000 leftover 2026 models to sell at a discount, with the discount coming out of your share, while the 2027s land at the same time. So you get to open your doors with cars that had a birthday before they ever reached your showroom. That is, if you’ve been able to hang on that long.
Merry Christmas
Now, being only in the car business, what could I know? I do know Christmas rolls around every year. There might be a Christmas party at the shiny new Chinese store, with the dealer handing out turkeys and bonus cheques.
Wanna bet? Both of his employees will be at their mother-in-law’s getting fed, because Grandma doesn’t want the grandkids to miss a whole Christmas.
Spring: the boom arrives
Picture this. Spring comes, cars finally start landing, the tariffs settle down. Lots of Chinese EVs to sell. It’s the boom, just like the mega dealers said it would be. But something strange is happening.
There are cars to sell, so what went wrong? Has the government been overthrown? No. But the Mazda dealer up the street closed overnight. How could that be? He was one of the biggest sellers of Mazda EVs in the province. And that little Nissan dealer out at the mall is a furniture store now. What’s going on?
Here’s what’s going on. The mega dealers who wanted a piece of the action didn’t figure out that every Chinese car they sold, along with the problems that come with it, was stealing an EV sale from their own Mazda showroom. And from their GM store. And their Toyota store. And their Acura store.
Holy Bondoli, they finally got it. We’re selling the same number of cars, with more overhead and more headaches. Every Chinese EV that rolls out of the new store is a Camry that didn’t roll out of the old one.
And don’t worry about the factories
And in the not-too-distant future, all our cars will be Chinese-made. That would be horrible, but relax. We know our wonderful government will keep those bad commie car builders out. We’d never let them get their hands on the empty Stellantis plant in Brampton, even though BYD has already come knocking, according to Brampton’s mayor. Or Windsor. Or Oshawa. Because we know they’d never really build all those cars they say they can.
That’s why they hardly build any cars today. 😊
Dealer to dealer
I love that these cars are coming. If I can keep my driver’s licence, a nice Chinese EV might just be my last car. But if you’re already a big, successful dealer, a $9 million Chinese palace isn’t adding money to your pile. It’s moving money around inside it.
Maybe the smarter play is a plain $4.5 million store aimed at a different customer, one who’s more comfortable in a plain dealership than a fancy one. I don’t know for sure. The market will decide that for itself. But run your numbers on the Camry you won’t sell before you sign anything.
— Tom
Comments